After leaving their sheltered Amish and Mennonite lives, Abe, Jeremiah, Kate, Rebecca and Sabrina experienced New York City together for the first time. Then, they traveled to Sarasota, Florida, in the series Breaking Amish: Brave New World. Now, with the exception of Kate, who’s living in New York and building her modeling career, the group has returned to Pennsylvania. Abe and Rebecca, still adjusting to married life, prepare to welcome a new baby into the family. Sabrina is also pregnant, but without the support of her Mennonite family, she’s on a difficult journey. Jeremiah has become an entrepreneur of sorts -- and is chasing love. Mary, Abe’s mother, struggles with being shunned by the community, and as her son Andrew is released from jail, he tries to start fresh with his on-again, off-again girlfriend Chapel and to mend his relationship with his family.
Sabrina overcomes nerves to speak in front of a college class; tension escalates between Rebecca and Sabrina; Esther makes a deal to experience English life.
Mary makes an Amish meal to bring everyone together and make peace; Jeremiah spends time with his kids in New York City; Rebecca and Abe discuss her job at the bakery; Sabrina goes on a special date.
An Old Christmas celebration brings the cast back to Pennsylvania. Meanwhile, Kate gets bad news about her internship; and dinner is interrupted by a confrontation between Jeremiah and Kate.